Back to search
Publication

Group affiliation in self-management: support or threat to identity?

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Self-management is considered important in chronic illness, and contemporary health policy recommends participation in support groups for individuals with chronic conditions. Although withdrawal from or non-participation in support groups is an important problem, there is limited knowledge about individuals' own motivation for participation in or withdrawal from self-management support groups.

OBJECTIVES: To investigate how individuals with type 2 diabetes perceive participation in group-based self-management support.

DESIGN: This is a qualitative focus group study using a semi-structured interview guide.

SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: Sixteen participants diagnosed with type 2 diabetes were included in the study. Individuals with and without group affiliations were mixed in three focus groups to trigger discussions. In the analysis, reoccurring themes of engagement and discussions between participants were focused within a theoretical frame of institutional logic. The focus groups are seen as social spaces where participants construct identity.

RESULTS: Both participation and non-participation in group-based self-management support are associated with dealing with the stigma of having type 2 diabetes. Negotiations contribute to constructing an illness dignity as a response to the logic of moral responsibility for the disease.

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION: Contemporary policy contributes to societal understandings of individuals with type 2 diabetes as morally inadequate. Our study shows that group-based self-management support may counteract blame and contribute in negotiations of identity for individuals with type 2 diabetes. This mechanism makes participation in groups beneficial for some but stigma inducing for others.

More information

Type
Journal Article
Author
Bossy D
Knutsen IR
Rogers A
Foss C
Year of Publication
2016
Journal
Health expectations : an international journal of public participation in health care and health policy
Language
eng
ISSN Number
1369-7625
DOI
10.1111/hex.12448
Alternate Journal
Health Expect
Publication Language
eng